Loading ...This week I’m chatting about a web application called Glue . I look at a good number of web applications, and some are useful. Unfortunately, Glue is not one of those.
The premise of Glue is that it “shows you things that you’ll like based on your personal tastes, what your friends like, and what’s most popular on Glue.” In essence, it’s a browser add-on that will allow you to rate certain kinds of things online and to share those likes/dislikes with people who subscribe (same as friend/follow) you.
I started experimenting with Glue several months ago as a beta participant. However, I soon gave up on it for a variety of reasons (which I’ll detail in a bit). Glue was released fully this month, and I decided to give it another go. Alas, I was disappointed–again. Here’s why:
- Glue is a browser add-on, which means you have to add it to every browser on every computer that you might use for surfing.
- It does not support every site on the net that might have books, movies, electronics, etc. I found that Glue worked fine with Amazon, but did not support Thinkgeek. The limited number of places on the web where Glue works was a deterrent for me.
- I wasn’t really sure what problem Glue was trying to solve. I believe it was using the idea that referencing your friends’ tastes would be useful when picking out items, but in practice it didn’t bear out. The issue comes down to critical mass; Glue doesn’t have it (at least, not yet). Only 9 of my “friends” were on Glue, and none of us necessarily have compatible tastes. The reality is that Glue, to work well, would likely need a community the size of Facebook to make it really useful.
Some of my other comments about this app:
- You can earn virtual “stickers” by continuing to favorite items. These icons show up on your Glue profile. However, some stickers showed up on mine with no real explanation of what they were or how I earned them. Additionally, marking just 10 movies gave me a sticker called “Movie Buff.” Really?
- If you spend enough time using Glue, you can eventually become a “Guru.” There is only one of these per category, so you will likely have to fight it out with other Glue users for the title.
- The idea that Glue was tracking what I was looking at and publicizing it made me a tad nervous. The app does give you the ability to manually delete items from your profile, but that assumes you’ll remember to do that. Granted, I’m not surfing porn, but what if I wasn’t looking to advertise my Betsy-Tacy habit?
What does this mean to me, Laura?
- Glue does not have the critical mass in users or supported sites to make this a truly useful application. Lack of community is a real issue.
- A library could theoretically make use of this for readers advisory services but, frankly, expecting users to have to install a browser plug-in to follow the library is unrealistic.
- Overall, this app has a long ways to go, if it ever gets there.
![[Bloglines]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/bloglines.png)
![[del.icio.us]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/delicious.png)
![[Digg]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/digg.png)
![[Facebook]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/facebook.png)
![[Fark]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/fark.png)
![[Furl]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/furl.png)
![[Google]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/google.png)
![[MySpace]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/myspace.png)
![[Reddit]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/reddit.png)
![[StumbleUpon]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/stumbleupon.png)
![[Technorati]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/technorati.png)
![[Twitter]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/twitter.png)
![[Windows Live]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/windowslive.png)
![[Yahoo!]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/yahoo.png)
![[Email]](http://www.oplin.org/meanlaura/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/email.png)
If your library is on Facebook, Twitter or other social media site, congratulations. You’ve started down the road to helping your library engage in new forms of communication and public relations. However, just being there isn’t enough, and it may not help you in the long run. It’s time to take the next step: building social capital. (Yes, I know, these posts are all about making more work for you, right?)
What is social capital?
Take a look at the Wikipedia definition. Essentially, social capital is connections to others. Not just the number of connections (although many marketers would have one believe that), but the quality of those connections. Numbers of friends/followers can be misleading. If you have a small number of connections and most of those consist of people who connect back and are active, you’re still better off than the company that just bought 1000 followers who don’t give a fig for the company.
Why do you need social capital?
When push comes to shove, it can allow your library to mobilize troops quickly. The Save Ohio Libraries campaign demonstrated this clearly. In less than 3 weeks, the associated Facebook group had more than 50,000 members; hundreds of tweets on Twitter used the #saveohiolibraries hashtag. OLC reported that the legislature had never seen a response as fast and heavy from the public. Is your library planning to go out for a levy? It may be too late this year to really build enough social capital to spend, but it’s never too early to start for the next time. Think of building social capital as building goodwill and direct connections. Not just direct connections into your community, but connections to a wider community that can get the word out for you.
So how do you build social capital?
There are entire books devoted to this topic, and many tips to help you (and maybe I’ll write about some more another day). I’m going to narrow all of it down to two basic things your library needs to do to get started.
- Turn the bullhorn around: Stop talking and start listening.* Who do you want to be friends with–the person who listens to all your stories, or the person who only talks about themselves? If your library is just promoting itself and not listening to its patrons, it will not build good relationships.
- Social media is about conversations. Start having them. This is really the corollary to #1. Don’t always wait for someone else to ask or comment first. Remember, people put this stuff out into the ether with the hope that someone will comment. Give your library a human voice. A sense of humor is critical.
What does this mean to me, Laura?
- Social media is a completely different way of doing PR. The good news, however, is that most of us know how to be human and talk to others of our species. It’s much less about promoting and much more about relating.
- Timing is important. When someone asks your library something or comments via a social network, it’s essential that a response be made–QUICKLY. Remember that a lot of this stuff is happening in near real-time. Make sure someone is monitoring your social media outlets constantly. (Remember, real social media is real work.)
- Don’t overplan. You don’t plan out every encounter you have with other people during the day; don’t do it with social media.
*From The Whuffie Factor by Tara Hunt.
- “Winners take imperfect action while others are sitting around perfecting their plans.” –Kevin Nation
- Be the voice that is remembered, not just heard.
- Don’t take yourself too seriously. Be willing to put yourself a bit “out there.”
- Be human. Corporate speak is unacceptable.
- Don’t be schizophrenic. Either talk from the perspective of your organization or from a personal standpoint, but not both.
- Beta is forever. Nothing is “finished.”
- Add value. What are *you* giving to the community? (Nothing? Then you’re a leech.)
- Once you know what value you provide, FOCUS on it. Don’t attempt to be all to all.
- Who’s the winner of the contest? The one who makes it to the top of the mountain, or the winner who lifted him there? Give props to others.
- Nobody likes a braggart. Brag when you have something to share that others can use.
- Get the lay of the land. Every community has standards. Even inadvertently violating them can cause you significant damage.
- Have an actual social media plan. Preferably a good one. Otherwise, you’re just treading water.
- You can’t hide from social media. Hiding hurts situations more than owning up. Know what to do when you get someone mad.
- Social media is the new WOM (word of mouth). It’s not only electronic, the speed of information is faster. Much faster. Be prepared.
- Weed your friends and followers just like you would any collection. Other people are looking at them just like you are and they’re making judgements.
- Social media takes TIME. To build social capital in any signficant way takes MORE time. Know it, schedule it, do it.
- Social media is not like the “Field of Dreams” in Kevin Costner’s film: you build it and nobody may come. Keep going.
- Grab your namespaces, complete the profiles, but don’t set up a complete shop in a million virtual places. Not every social tool is for everyone. Pick 3 and call it a day.
- Tailor your social media work (yes, it’s work!) to each service. The one-size-fits-all approach=#EPICFAIL
- Social media is about building connections to PEOPLE. If you’re not doing that, you’re wasting time.
_______________________
With acknowledgement to the article by Mari Smith
Social networking is here to stay, in form or another. I think we all get it now; this stuff can no longer be considered a fad, but is now an integral part of our culture. But that doesn’t mean that some forms or services won’t fall out of favor. Or that you won’t throw up your hands in frustration over the influx of daily minutia you might be consuming. At some point, you will likely feel the need to scale back, retool and/or disconnect from a service altogether. In this post I’d like to offer some guidelines about how to do that.
However, before doing anything, you need to ask yourself a couple of questions and to be brutally honest with yourself:
- What am I running from? If you’re considering leaving a social media service entirely, you need to understand why. Are you tired from trying to keep up with all of the stuff your friends/followers create? Are there specific people you’re trying to avoid? Is the service not what you thought it would be? Before you leave and cancel an account, be sure there isn’t an alternative solution, such as dropping some friends/followers. Remember, even if you haven’t been the most active person in that service, you’ve still built some credibility and some social capital by being there. Consider carefully before you pull the plug. Rebuilding social capital can be a long (and sometimes impossible) process.
- Were my expectations in line with what is possible to get out of it? If you were expecting hundreds of friends/followers after several months, the answer to this question is likely “no.” It’s not just a matter of time; if you rarely updated your Facebook status and never tweeted anything of interest that got re-tweeted or replied to by others, you weren’t putting in the work required to get all those friends and followers. Social media is just that–social. If you’re not being social (constantly, yes!) then you flunked Social Media 101. Be honest here–did you participate fully? Do you plan to in the future?
So, now you’ve decided you need to do…something. Here’s some first steps:
- Take a hiatus*. There’s nothing wrong with taking a break from social media. Simply announce to your friends/followers that you’re taking a break for a week or two, and not to worry if your feed goes quiet for a while. Re-evaluate how you feel about things after you come back.
- Scale back what you see. Everyone likely has Facebook friends that they friended well…just because. Not because you necessarily wanted to know the intimate details of their lives. Maybe you just didn’t want to offend them. Did you know that you can actually hide people’s updates in your Facebook timeline? Paring down what you actually see in FB can make a huge difference. You can also do the same for Twitter. Someone posting out of a conference every 2 minutes and you’ve had enough? Put them on Twittersnooze. These methods are low-to-no-guilt and give you a little peace.
- Scale back your friends/followers. This is a more drastic step, because you risk offending others and/or losing social capital**. Unfriending people on Facebook is a tricky proposition. Although the unfriended person gets no notifications, chances are that they are not stupid and are going to realize fairly soon what you’ve done. If you’re planning to pare down Facebook friends, it might help to explain that you’re only keeping immediate family and close friends and not work acquaitances or some such, to minimize the backlash. Many people have mixed both work and personal lives in Facebook; sometimes this can cause discomfort later. Separating out your lives is a valid reason for paring down. That doesn’t mean you won’t offend anyone, unfortunately. As for Twitter–it’s a little easier to stop following on Twitter. Overall, Twitter followers are more ephemeral and less likely to have a close connection to you. If you stop following someone on Twitter though, be aware that it is likely that they will return the favor.
Canceling a social media account is, undoubtedly, the last resort. If it’s a personal account (for you, not your library), it’s probably better to just let it lie unused. Everyone kind of lags on keeping up with things, and if you come back to it later and pick up the pace, people will understand. Better to let it lie fallow than to burn the field.
If this is a library’s account, it’s not as simple. If the only friends/followers you have are other libraries/librarians, the account wasn’t doing what it should have been doing anyway–reaching out to the public. If you have patrons, then you have to decide if the account is worth reviving. Could your library be doing more with this account? The answer is almost always “certainly.” But do you have the time to invest in it? Social media is time-intensive. To pretend otherwise is self-delusional. If there isn’t staff time to maintain it, it might be best to let it go.
However, with a library account, under no circumstances (that I can think of) should it ever be canceled. Why? That namespace is priceless. If you let that account be deleted, then someone else can come along and grab “XYZ Library.” This is why I tell libraries to get social media accounts, even if they never use them. Protect your library from brandjacking whenever possible. If you don’t plan to maintain that account, post a message to that effect and give folks info about which social media services you are maintaining.
____________________________________________________________
*Those of you who know me on Twitter and Facebook know that I attempted to take a social media hiatus a couple of weeks ago, before the whole Ohio library budget thing happened. Then my life got eaten by social media. Timing is everything.
**One of my next posts is going to be on social capital, I promise. It’s an extremely important part of social media. If you don’t have it, you’re just about dead in the water.
